Makes 1 sandwich • About 20 minutes, and 15 of those are the tomatoes resting
The Sandwich
This is the one I make most often. Everything after it is “extra.”
Ingredients:
- 2 slices soft white sandwich bread (I like Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White)
- Duke’s mayonnaise
- 1 large ripe tomato, at room temperature
- Fine sea salt
- Freshly cracked black pepper
Directions:
- Slice and salt the tomato. Cut the tomato into slices a good half-inch thick. Thin slices get lost between the bread. Lay them on a rack set over a plate, salt both sides, and walk away for 15 minutes. The salt pulls out water that would otherwise end up in your bread, and what stays behind tastes more like tomato than it did before.
- Blot. Press the slices gently with a paper towel. No need to squeeze them; you want them drained, not dry.
- Mayonnaise, edge to edge. Spread Duke’s across both slices of bread, all the way into the crust. There is a reason beyond generosity. The fat forms a barrier that keeps the tomato juice from soaking straight through the bread.
- Assemble and pepper. Stack the tomato slices on one piece of bread, crack black pepper over them, and close the sandwich. Cut it however you like it. It is best right away, while the bread is still dry underneath.
Liz’s Notes:
On the tomato. German Johnson and Cherokee Purple are good Carolina sandwich tomatoes—broad-shouldered, meaty, and not full of seeds and water. Any good heirloom from a roadside stand will do you right. What matters far more than the variety is that it never sees the inside of a refrigerator. Cold destroys the aroma compounds that make a tomato taste like a tomato, and it is not a change you can undo by letting it warm back up.
On the bread. Plain soft white sandwich bread is my preference, but to each their own. As much as I love sourdough, it’s too chewy, and can cause tomato slices to go sliding out when you bite into it if you’re not careful.
On the mayonnaise. Use the real thing, full-fat—nothing labeled light, reduced calorie, et cetera, unless that truly is your favorite for taste reasons. Duke’s carries more egg yolk than most and no added sugar, which is why it tastes tangy instead of sweet against a ripe tomato.
Ways Liz & I Have Been Known to Gild this Lily
Add Bacon. Natural uncured bacon, baked at 400 on a wire rack set over a foil-lined sheet pan. The rack earns its keep here: the strips stay flat instead of curling, so they lie down across the tomato instead of shoving everything out the sides on the first bite.
Add Sweet Onion. Vidalia if have one, sliced paper-thin, with a mandoline if you have one. This is the version that starts arguments at family reunions.
Pimento Cheese Instead of Mayonnaise. Homemade, with cheese grated off the block. Liz has a particular fondness for it, and pimento cheese is mayonnaise-adjacent anyway, so the sandwich hardly notices the substitution. Spread it a little thicker than you think you should.
Roasted Garlic Mayonnaise. Cut the top off a whole head of garlic, drizzle it with olive oil, wrap it in foil, and roast at 400°F until the cloves go soft and golden, about 40 minutes. Squeeze them out, mash them smooth, and stir them into Duke’s with a little lemon zest. Roasting turns garlic sweet and nutty instead of sharp, which is what lets you use a whole head without wrecking the tomato. Make it the day you plan to fire up the oven for something else.
The Half-and-Half. One slice fried green tomato, one slice ripe red. Crisp against soft, tart against sweet.
The Melt. A different animal entirely. Yes, it means turning on the broiler. Some things are worth it.
Ingredients:
- 2 slices soft white sandwich bread
- Duke’s mayonnaise, for both faces of both slices
- 3 to 4 strips natural uncured bacon, cooked crisp
- 1 large ripe tomato, sliced, salted, and drained
- 1 – 2 slices Tillamook sharp cheddar
- Freshly cracked black pepper
How to Build It:
- Drain the tomatoes first. Half-inch slices, salted, 15 minutes on a rack, blotted dry. Draining is optional in the cold sandwich. Under a broiler it is not. An undrained tomato will flood the toast.
- Mayonnaise both sides of the bread. Spread Duke’s on the outside faces and the inside faces both. Mayonnaise on the griddle side browns better than butter—it is oil and egg, with no milk solids to scorch, so it goes evenly golden at a lower temperature and never turns bitter on you. The mayonnaise on the inside does its usual job of sealing the bread against the tomato.
- Grill the bread. Set a skillet or griddle over medium heat and toast both slices until deep golden, 2 to 3 minutes a side. Move them to a foil-lined sheet pan, grilled side down, so the crisp face is protected.
- Build it open-face. Start with one slice of the bread, top with bacon first, tomato on top of the bacon, pepper, then the cheddar on top.
- Broil. Slide the pan about 6 inches under a hot broiler for 60 to 90 seconds, until the cheese bubbles. Stay with it. Broilers vary, and I’ve burnt my share.
- Top with remaining slice of bread and enjoy.
On the cheese…use sharp, not extra-sharp. Aged cheddars have a more broken-down protein structure and break into oil under direct heat. Tillamook sharp melts smooth.
Enjoy!














